A friend of mine on the muck recently made the comment how she finds little fun in RPing at Redwall anymore which, honestly, is for me a sad thing to hear. The reason for her loss of enthusiasm? Well, nobody (at least how my friend sees it) seems to like the idea of RPing a happy character. Of what she has seen (and I agree now that she mentions it), many of the RPs at the Abbey tend to be filled with pity parties and tension.
I do know of a couple, but I think it's safe to say that there are not many instances in the books where there was a prolonged gloom in the Abbey. I know how on the muck, bad stuff has happened to the Abbey in the past, some really bad stuff in fact. And, from that perspective, I suppose people have a right to be 'mopey' as my friend put it, whether it's over the Abbey's condition or in response to their characters' personal woes and/or grudges.
But perhaps this notion has been carried on longer than necessary. If my friend (who is a long-time player on the muck) is becoming disillusioned about RP at Redwall, I highly doubt it leaves any better of an impression to the new players of the muck. Plus, how are we supposed to expect the Abbey to be restored to what it once was, when this kind of angst and pessimism seems to prevail?
I say it's time that the beasts of the Abbey (myself included) lighten up, and ICly have something to be happy or optimistic about for a change. You don't get any new songs by playing the same record over and over again. You want good and happy things to happen for Redwall? Then play the part!
Comment
Thank you!
Posted by:
Toniat
2005-03-04
I know of some (perhaps who you're speaking of) that are finding everything gloomy lately. There seems to be more than the normal amount of self-indulgent RP going on, and it's not just Redwall Abbey. I know I've done my share as well, but if everyone could just cheer up... that'd be awesome.
Comment
I tend to agree
Posted by:
otterat
2005-03-05
Not that the Abbey is particularly gloomy compared to other places, but that there's not as much pleasure and joy as gloom and doom in many RPs that I see.
When I take Nicodemus out, he's a cheerful sort. But it takes a lot of cheer to counte a single "My parents were killed by vermin hug me!" cry.
It's easier just to leave at that point, and the RP dies.
In the books, even those beasts who suffered terrible losses weren't gloomy. They were melancholy at times, and they had sorrows and they mourned, but, life goes on and life is too short to spend in misery.
Otter
Comment
And why is the Abbey always in peril?
Posted by:
Shalinaat
2005-03-29
Well, perhaps not always, but there always seem to be some sort of crisis upon the other, and nothing seems to be done about it. Like the earthquake event, which was a long time ago. The gates still haven't been rebuilt, and the clock tower is still a heap of rubble on the grounds as if to rub in just how stricken and defenseless the abbey is. And there's always at least someone in the Great Hall either moping about it, or mocking it, or being negative in some other way.
We need more cheerful characters, or at least characters who actually do something except polish their swords and mope about vermin.
I do know of a couple, but I think it's safe to say that there are not many instances in the books where there was a prolonged gloom in the Abbey. I know how on the muck, bad stuff has happened to the Abbey in the past, some really bad stuff in fact. And, from that perspective, I suppose people have a right to be 'mopey' as my friend put it, whether it's over the Abbey's condition or in response to their characters' personal woes and/or grudges.
But perhaps this notion has been carried on longer than necessary. If my friend (who is a long-time player on the muck) is becoming disillusioned about RP at Redwall, I highly doubt it leaves any better of an impression to the new players of the muck. Plus, how are we supposed to expect the Abbey to be restored to what it once was, when this kind of angst and pessimism seems to prevail?
I say it's time that the beasts of the Abbey (myself included) lighten up, and ICly have something to be happy or optimistic about for a change. You don't get any new songs by playing the same record over and over again. You want good and happy things to happen for Redwall? Then play the part!
Comment
Thank you!
Posted by: Toni at 2005-03-04I know of some (perhaps who you're speaking of) that are finding everything gloomy lately. There seems to be more than the normal amount of self-indulgent RP going on, and it's not just Redwall Abbey. I know I've done my share as well, but if everyone could just cheer up... that'd be awesome.
Comment
I tend to agree
Posted by: otter at 2005-03-05Not that the Abbey is particularly gloomy compared to other places, but that there's not as much pleasure and joy as gloom and doom in many RPs that I see.
When I take Nicodemus out, he's a cheerful sort. But it takes a lot of cheer to counte a single "My parents were killed by vermin hug me!" cry.
It's easier just to leave at that point, and the RP dies.
In the books, even those beasts who suffered terrible losses weren't gloomy. They were melancholy at times, and they had sorrows and they mourned, but, life goes on and life is too short to spend in misery.
Otter
Comment
And why is the Abbey always in peril?
Posted by: Shalina at 2005-03-29Well, perhaps not always, but there always seem to be some sort of crisis upon the other, and nothing seems to be done about it. Like the earthquake event, which was a long time ago. The gates still haven't been rebuilt, and the clock tower is still a heap of rubble on the grounds as if to rub in just how stricken and defenseless the abbey is. And there's always at least someone in the Great Hall either moping about it, or mocking it, or being negative in some other way. We need more cheerful characters, or at least characters who actually do something except polish their swords and mope about vermin.
Replies to this comment
Comment
Big RP Times
Posted by: Emryn at 2005-04-08When is the best rp time in Redwall Abbey? It always seems deserted.